First we look at the people from this pool who our methods rank higher than Pantheon. By definition, all of these people will be highly regarded by both of our rankings. It is clear that we favor American and British leaders higher than they do, because we analyze only the English Wikipedia :
860 907 47 Woodrow Wilson U.S. President
841 996 155 Edward I of England British King
776 961 185 Leonhard Euler Mathematician
674 697 23 Theodore Roosevelt U.S. President
634 799 165 John Milton British Poet/Philosopher
600 985 385 Alexander II of Russia Russian Czar
583 789 206 Edward VI of England British King
556 666 110 Dwight D. Eisenhower U.S. President
553 970 417 John Dewey American Educator
550 954 404 Alexander I of Russia Russian Czar
542 636 94 Harry S. Truman U.S. President
539 654 115 Bill Clinton U.S. President
538 889 351 Francis I of France French King
536 936 400 Soren Kierkegaard Danish Philosopher
530 563 33 Charles Dickens British Writer
524 594 70 William the Conqueror British King
509 815 306 Jacques Cartier French explorer of America
505 742 237 Henry IV of France French King
503 677 174 Geoffrey Chaucer British Writer
498 616 118 Lewis Carroll British Writer
495 762 267 Alfred the Great British King
486 962 476 Eleanor of Aquitaine French/British Queen Consort
446 809 363 George H. W. Bush U.S. President
442 983 541 Archduke Franz Ferdinand Proximate cause of WWI
441 900 459 John Wayne U.S. actor and "Duke"
439 545 106 Alexander Graham Bell Inventor of the telephone
Still, these are figures who are generally quite familiar to me: I've heard of all of them, although I would not be confident in my ability to tell one Alexander from the other. By contrast, there are several figures among the ones they rank much higher than we do who I could not place, or place as celebrities more than historical figures:
-7960 673 8633 Justin Bieber Teenaged popular singer
-8008 943 8951 Haruki Murakami Japanese novelist
-8460 850 9310 Carus Short-ruling Roman Emperor
-8463 765 9228 Antisthenes Greek Philosopher
-8601 880 9481 Jenna Jameson American porn star
-8630 734 9364 Anacreon Greek Poet
-8746 363 9109 Anaximenes of Miletus Greek Philosopher
-8836 352 9188 James son of Alphaeus One of Jesus' twelve apolstles
-8932 919 9851 Polykleitos Greek sculptor
-9008 934 9942 Lysippos Greek sculptor
-9674 851 10525 Carinus Roman Emperor with Carus (above)
-9866 671 10537 Hor-Aha Egyptian Pharaoh
-10628 920 11548 Kaka Brazilian soccer player
-10696 775 11471 Orhan Pamuk Turkish novelist
-11153 839 11992 Abu Nuwas Classical Arabic poet
-11722 906 12628 Trebonianus Gallus Short-ruling Roman Emperor
-11771 560 12331 Praxiteles Greek sculptor
-11834 368 12202 Vitellius Very short-ruling Roman Emperor
-13291 607 13898 Gaius Maecenas Roman political advisor
-14507 701 15208 Milan Kundera Contemporary Czech novelist
-14571 843 15414 Emir Kusturica Bosnian filmmaker
-16783 610 17393 Paulo Coelho Brazilian novelist
-19060 820 19880 Monica Bellucci Italian actress and model
-21652 737 22389 Francois Villon French poet of the Middle Ages
-22604 974 23578 Pedro Almodovar Spanish Film director
-22754 935 23689 Quintillus Short-lived Roman Emperor
-26427 963 27390 Jean Reno French actor
This roster makes clear the differences in our models for aging historical reputations. About half of these historically-overvalued people are relatively minor figures from ancient times: short-lived Emperors and second-tier philosophers/poets/artists. Many of the rest are contemporary celebrities who don't really belong in anyone's top thousand historical figures, like porn star Jenna Jameson.
There are also a few international artists of real stature (including Orhan Pamuk, Milan Kundera, and Pedro Almodvar) who might be undervalued by the English Wikipedia relative to international editions. Still, I think our rankings place them in the right order of magnitude.
